Rowling: Potter's Dumbledore Gay
By AP/HILLEL ITALIE Saturday, Oct. 20, 2007
Based her on fan fiction Rowling came to this conclusion, it wasn’t due to what Rowling planned long ago but what some 16 year old girl concluded based on faulty logic. Therefore uses some sort of ‘Darwinian’ method to shape the world that she created, in which she plays the role of nature and chooses which mutation will stick and which will pass into time, whatever it is her book but I wish this puppet master would use a bit of critical thinking.
The basis in which some fans see Dumbledore as gay is he has no close relationships with women, and has a troubled past. Considering a majority of her fans are teenagers, ‘love’ and sex tends to, saturate their world. Their hormonal factories are in start up and still calibrating, some sprout like weeds, some remain stunted until the end of their adolescence. Most teenagers have problems with acne because their oil glands increased activity. Yes, their diet does not help matter. Yet for many this diet remains into the latter parts of puberty when these factories are close to their correct settings, and yet the zits decrease.
Let us walk through there observations. They claim Dumbledore must be gay because he does not have doesn’t have any close relations with women. If Dumbledore were gay he would be like any other person, homosexuality does not take from his libido, only modify the flavor of it’s longing. I always thought of Dumbledore as dedicated to his work. He is the ultimate administrator. His job is to craft young boys and girls into wizards and witches. This is a dangerous task, and I’m sure take a lot of his time. Harry’s earlier years at Hogwarts most of his attention was placed on Harry. The risk of Harry becoming a poisoned dragon, or killed by the followers of Valdemort, and living in a house of muggles that hated wizardry required Dumbledore to keep a close eye on Harry.
If Rowling wants Dumbledore to be gay then fine, I think it would damage the story for me but sure, make him gay. However put some stronger evidence than he has no love life. Hell I have no love life, especially in the way the world would have me paint what love should be, but it doesn’t keep me from watching some cute tail once in awhile, I just don’t see any reason for any sort of relationship. Lacking any evidence as to one way or the other I would thank Rowling to keep her personal views out of my reading thank you. If she didn’t intend him to be one way or the other then allow me, not some 16 year old, to shape the world I’m immersing myself in.
It happened again!
14 years ago